When I got my new MacBook Pro a couple months back, I installed
Vista Ultimate via BootCamp and have had few problems, but Nick is absolutely
correct. Simple tasks are far more cumbersome and not at all
intuitive. Performance wise, the machine runs great, but stability is
another story. The system itself is a rock, but IE seems to stop
responding far more often than it should (yes, I should be using Firefox, but I
personally like IE :P). General usability is not so much a factor, as
that’s an overall positive experience, but for people that are not at all
savvy, it’s going to pose a lot of challenges. Particularly as Nick
mentioned with networking. Once the cable is plugged in, you have to
authorize the system at least twice, then categorize the connection before it
actually connects.
I’m hoping that SP1 will address many of the complaints
from the supposed 40 million licensed user base. I won’t even start
in on software compatibility as that’s just a mess in itself, but for
now, International Studies and Programs isn’t even considering Vista
anytime soon. With a potential 150 users, it’s a training nightmare
just waiting to happen that none of us are ready to tackle. Plus the fact
that the domain is still on NT4, means that each Vista installation needs to me
manually dumbed down in the registry to get to join L.
Jon
Jon Galbreath
MCSA/MCSE/Security+
Network/System Administrator
International Studies and Programs
Ph: 517-355-2350
From: MSU Network
Administrators Group [mailto:[log in to unmask]] On Behalf Of Kwiatkowski,
Nicholas
Sent: Tuesday, August 07, 2007 5:32 PM
To: [log in to unmask]
Subject: Re: [MSUNAG] Recent / upcoming Windows Vista deployments?
I personally have been very disappointed in Vista. I had a
hard drive fail on my personal laptop, which Dell was happy to replace with a
Vista image (I didn’t order the media for XP, so I didn’t get the
opportunity to switch back). My DVD software, anti-virus software, VPN
and all sorts of other software was incompatible. I ended up installing
Virtual PC to VPN to my remote machines (ending up in a window within a window
within a window).
I have found some features which are kinda nice – I like some
of the UI changes, but some tasks have become 10 fold more difficult, if not
impossible with the new OS. Simple tasks such as changing your IP address
requires you to go into 8 screens (and 9 clicks of the mouse) instead of the
former 3 clicks.
SP1 is in the works, according to Paul Thurrott from WinInfo.
It may require the wait until that is released, or not. Many
vendors are using the upgrade to Vista as a chance to sell customers new
versions of software (and to obsolete old software).
-Nick Kwiatkowski
MSU Telecom Systems
From: MSU Network
Administrators Group [mailto:[log in to unmask]] On Behalf Of Richard
Wiggins
Sent: Tuesday, August 07, 2007 5:01 PM
To: [log in to unmask]
Subject: Re: [MSUNAG] Recent / upcoming Windows Vista deployments?
I heard back from a few folks:
-- One entire academic department is going to Vista either
late this year or early in '08.
-- One unit just rolled out 30 new machines running Vista.
-- One unit has 10 laptops in production running Vista.
-- One person cited two "entities" that rolled out
Vista and the rollouts turned into disasters due to custom software that wasn't
compatible.
A couple of you asked why I posed the question. The
particular reason is because I'm working on an article on Vista for computing.msu.edu. More generally,
I'm wondering how big an impact Vista will make when classes start. I
expect several thousand new student computers running Vista, but haven't heard
much here lately.
As I've researched my article and read reviewers' advice,
and based on my own experience, I believe that people should be strongly
discouraged from upgrading to Vista on an existing computer. If you're
buying a new computer that comes with Vista, that's a different picture.
But I upgraded a Thinkpad Z61t and had all sorts of problems. For
instance, none of the 4 DVD players on my computer can play a conventional
video DVD any more. I've tried adding codecs to no avail. Windows
Media Player puts out this not-very-helpful message:
Windows Media Player cannot play DVD video. You might need to adjust your Windows display settings. Open display settings in Control Panel, and then try lowering your screen resolution and color quality settings.
/rich