I think that Ehren is making a very good point here.
Plus, I think that the load that you are listing is a little too much for a workstation. I would go for a low end server.
I would be looking for two power sources and future memory scalability and things like that.


oscar



On 6/17/2014 4:12 PM, Benson, Ehren wrote:
[log in to unmask]" type="cite">

Really it comes down to the criticality of the systems running on it.  Can a high end workstation run many server VM’s yes.  But you have to account for if/when it would go down and how often that may occur being a workstation with less redundancy than a server, and also being a single system rather than a cluster or multiple systems.  If they are unimportant and can be down for a day or two if something horrible happens, then absolutely, if not then you may want to consider something else higher end.

 

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Ehren Benson

IT Services Virtualization Storage & Systems (VSS)

517-884-3088 | [log in to unmask]

 

From: Al Puzzuoli [mailto:[log in to unmask]]
Sent: Tuesday, June 17, 2014 3:55 PM
To: [log in to unmask]
Subject: [MSUNAG] Running Non Critical Virtual Servers on a High End Workstation, Good idea or not?

 

Hi everyone,

We are looking to free up space in our office by getting rid of our big server cabinet. In order to facilitate this, the plan is to virtualize our critical servers, Exchange and one domain controller at IT Services. We will then buy a Workstation level PC with a Zeon processor, something like the Lenovo P300 to host several less critical and less performance intensive virtual machines. These will include a web server, file server for 25 or so users, VPN server, software license server, etc. For this use case, is there any real reason to consider a low end server instead of a higher end workstation like the P300? It would seem the P300 would give us all the expandability and reliability we would need at a lower price point, and take up significantly less space than most servers as well.

Thanks for any thoughts,

Al Puzzuoli

Information Technologist

Michigan State University,

Resource Center for Persons with Disabilities,  120 Bessey Hall East Lansing, MI  48824-1033

517-884-1915

http://www.rcpd.msu.edu

 


--
Oscar Castañeda
Remote Sensing & GIS
Michigan State University