This is a topic that is similar to asking "What kind of computer should I buy?" which is kind of like asking a group of people "What kind of car should I buy?"  

I had an iPhone 3GS for over a year and liked it from the get go.  I upgraded to a 4S about a month ago.  It's much faster.  The display is gorgeous.  I'd previously upgraded to iOS 5 on the old phone, but it zings along well on the 4S.  Reviews show how much better the camera is.  The flash is pretty good and there are 3rd party apps that turn it into a flashlight.

When I first got the 3GS I had lots of problems with dropped calls.  That gradually improved, I assume as AT&T improved its network.  The 4S has a dual antenna setup and the antenna problem is solved.

The iPhone 4s is not an LTE phone on any provider.  Tests show its data performance is poor on Verizon because you fall back to 3G, which is slow on Verizon but more advanced on AT&T.  The FCC speed test (see  http://www.broadband.gov/qualitytest/ ) shows 2.5 Mbps download and about 1 Mbps upload.  An LTE phone on Verizon can scream.  AT&T is rolling out LTE now.

Siri is fun but I'm not as wild about it as some are.  My favorite Siri "huh" is if I ask "key west cameras" I get back "Sorry I can't places in Iceland."

My main concern is battery life.  As you use the phone for its smartphone features that chew up a lot of battery (music, camera, video) you chew up battery fast. If you are shooting video in the field you may eat up your talk time. The irreplaceable battery is criminal.

While I'm sure you'll get lots of good advice here, you might want to check out other forums.  There is a lot of fervor out there.  There's also some helpful reviews at places like PCMAG.

On Sun, Dec 18, 2011 at 9:17 PM, Charlot, Firmin <[log in to unmask]> wrote:
Hello Fellow NAGers,
I am in need of some advise in choosing a new phone and I need your help.

Currently I have an iPhone 3G which was wonderful when I first got it a number of years ago but now it ... Uh hmmm ... Well loosing its appeal - between dropped calls through AT&T and the lack of flash on the phone among other things, it's time for a change.  Sprint's service plans sound good but what would an alternative phone be?

It would help me great if you could answer the following questions:
 What type of phone do you have now?
 Why did you decide to buy?
 What's your favorite feature?
If you had to choose all over again, what phone would you go with and why?

Thank you and goodnight.

Firm.