 |
 |
Nothing is checked there. I'm pretty sure this machine never had the firewall turned on, under SP1. -John (trying hard to quote correctly and send to the list!) Chris Wolf wrote: > Have you looked at the Windows Firewall settings on the Advanced tab, ICMP Settings? > > At 12:58 PM 8/16/2004, John Valenti wrote: > >>I have a test box at 35.10.69.251 >>It was upgraded to SP2 last week, I haven't changed any settings from >>default. If I ping it from a windows box, I get "request timed out". >> >>I've also portscanned two SP2 systems with the Internet Tools GUI in Mac >>OS X, both systems came back with no ports open. >> >>-John >> >> >> >>>Chris Wolf wrote: >>> >>> >>> >>>>At Friday's NAG meeting, several people seemed to be claiming that the Windows Firewall in XP SP2 blocks pings by default, and thus would break some things, such as MSU's ability to properly manage DHCP addresses. >>>> >>>>I checked this out on the computer where I installed SP2 last week. I found that the default ICMP settings for the firewall have "Allow incoming echo request" turned on, and all other settings off. When I ping this computer from another one I get a normal response. >>>> >>>>Does this mean that there is no problem? Is anyone else finding a different default setting or getting ping failures? Thanks. >>> >>> >>>I'd be interested in hearing someone who can corroborate Chris's findings. >>>If ICMP is indeed enabled, then it would appear that Microsoft actually >>>listened to us during the beta period.