AEJMC Archives

AEJMC Archives


View:

Next Message | Previous Message
Next in Topic | Previous in Topic
Next by Same Author | Previous by Same Author
Chronologically | Most Recent First
Proportional Font | Monospaced Font

Options:

Join or Leave AEJMC
Reply | Post New Message
Search Archives


Subject: AEJ 95 BridgesJ MCS Messages about alcohol consumption in network TV
From: Elliott Parker <[log in to unmask]>
Reply-To:AEJMC Conference Papers <[log in to unmask]>
Date:Tue, 6 Feb 1996 13:02:34 EST
Content-Type:text/plain
Parts/Attachments:
Parts/Attachments

text/plain (1185 lines)


Health Belief Messages about Alcohol Consumption in Network Television
Entertainment
 
         Programs:
A Preliminary Report
 
 
by
Janet A. Bridges
Associate Professor of Communication
University of Southwestern Louisiana
Lafayette LA 70504-3650
 
318-482-6142
 
 
with Christine M. Price and Terri R. Breaux
Graduate Students
Department of Communication
University of Southwestern Louisiana
Lafayette LA 70504-3650
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Submitted to the Mass Communication and Society Division of the Association for
Education
 
            in Journalism and Mass Communication, annual meeting, Washington DC,
August 1995
 
The author wishes to thank Jung-Sook Lee and the late Robert E. Simmons for
their comments
 when this project was conceptualized.
An Abstract
 
Health Belief Messages about Alcohol Consumption in Network Television
Entertainment
 
         Programs:
A Preliminary Report
 
 
by
Janet A. Bridges
Associate Professor of Communication
University of Southwestern Louisiana
 
with Christine M. Price and Terri R. Breaux
Graduate Students
Department of Communication
University of Southwestern Louisiana
 
 
 
 
Messages about expectations from alcohol use in 103 television entertainment
programs
 
                indicated that alcohol use is most frequently portrayed as
affecting social enhancement;
 
            second most frequently  alcohol is associated with relaxation, and
thirdly with a
 
     ssertiveness.
Soaps and nonsoap evening programs were not different in associating social
enhancement
 
                  and assertiveness with alcohol, but nonsoap evening programs
had many more messages
 
        associating alcohol use with relaxation.Evening nonsoap programs
associate alcohol with
 
            aggression more often than the soaps.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Submitted to the Mass Communication and Society Division of the Association for
Education
 
            in Journalism and Mass Communication, annual meeting, Washington DC,
August 1995
 
 
Health Belief Messages about Alcohol Consumption in Network Television
Entertainment
 
         Programs:
A Preliminary Report
_______________________________
 
 
 
 
Health Belief Messages about Alcohol Consumption in Network Television
Entertainment
 
         Programs:
A Preliminary Report
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
The social costs of alcoholism in the United States have been estimated at more
than $116
 
                  billion yearly (Carroll, 1989; Harwood, 1984; Blume, 1984,
1981).  Alcoholism, the
 
       nation's third largest health problem, affects approximately 25 percent
of the homes
 
         (Carroll, 1989; National Council on Alcoholism, 1987).
Research in the health fields has attempted to identify, if not causes of
alcohol abuse,
 
                  at least correlates of increasing consumption of alcoholic
beverages, as well as methods
 
            of treatment. Biological factors have been studied, but recent
studies have focused on the
 individual's environment as a possible predictor of that individual's alcohol
use.
 
        Entertainment television, an integral part of most individuals'
environments, can provide
 
            subtle messages about appropriate behavior and consequences of
behavior in terms of
 
        beliefs about the effects of alcohol.
Alcohol Use in Media Content: The cues in television programs about alcohol use
are
 
              myriad.   A recent report picked up in the news media suggests
that "a child will watch
 
            someone take a drink on TV an average of 100,000 times by the time
he turns 18."  The
 
          report said some characters in late prime-time programs will take a
drink on the average
 
            of once every 20 minutes (American Health and Psychology Today
Service, 1989).
Signorielli (1987) said National Opinion Research Center (NORC) data on whether
an
 
             individual uses alcohol was modestly and negatively (r= -.05)
correlated with television
 
            use. Controlling for sex, age, education, income and race made the
relationship positive
 
            (r= .028).  Both correlations were very low, but statistically
significant.  Signorielli
 
            noted that through 1985 the proportion of entertainment programs
referring to alcohol in
 
            one form or another increased linearly, as did the proportion of
programs mentioning the
 
            harmful effects of alcohol.
A study of adolescents concluded that drinking on popular television programs
was done by
 
                  "good guys," sending a message to teenagers that drinking is a
desirable behavior
 
       (Smoking Taboo, 1991).
Lowry (1981) found 30 "negative short-term consequences" of drinking in 120
hours of  1979
 prime-time television programs, but 14  of these were comic intoxication.  Only
four
 
                "negative long-term consequences" were noted.  Lowry found an
average of 3.38 drinking
 
           acts per hour.
The National Institute of Mental Health's report on Television and Behavior
(Gerbner,
 
                Morgan and Signorielli, 1982) indicated that during evening
hours alcohol use averages no
 
            less than one and one-half acts per program, increasing to no less
than three drinking
 
           acts in the later prime-time hours.   For the daytime soap operas, at
least 6 drinking
 
           incidents per hour are the norm.  Thirty-six percent of the major
characters are drinking
 
            (Gerbner, et al., 1982).   Wallack, et al., (1990) found that
evening soap operas averaged
 13.3 acts of alcohol drinking per hour.
Signorielli (1990) said early studies on daytime soap operas found more women
than men
 
                 characters are problem drinkers, and these drinkers are upper
rather than lower class.
 
            Her own research found that in prime time problem drinkers were more
likely to be men. A
 
            case study with one of the daytime soaps (Wallack, et al., 1985)
found "several good role
 
            models for social drinking and abstinence" and "negative
reinforcement for heavier or high
 risk drinking." The NIMH study found that 48 percent of the women in
adventure/crime
 
          programs are drinking (Gerbner, et al., 1982).
Media Content and Alcohol Use:  No direct evidence links drinking behavior on
 
        entertainment television to drinking behavior in real life, but research
evidence suggests
 that the mass media, especially television, provide an indirect learning
environment for
 
            heavy viewers, who tend to perceive life and the world more like the
world as shown on
 
           television than like real life itself .  (For a discussion of
possible effects of heavy
 
            viewing, see Gerbner, et al., 1986; Morgan and Signorielli, 1990;
Ball-Rokeach and
 
       DeFleur, 1979; or DeFleur and Ball-Rokeach, 1989.  McQuail (1987)
presents a good
 
      discussion of unintentional media effects.)  In a face-to-face situation,
Caudill and
 
          Marlatt's (1975) experiment found that modeling behavior, long
considered an indirect
 
          effect of television viewing, was associated with drinking behavior.
Subjects in their
 
           study with a heavy drinking model drank significantly more in a
social situation than
 
          subjects with a model who drank little or who didn't drink.
Health Beliefs: There is little research that seeks to identify specific belief
dimensions
 that  underlie specific behaviors, such as decisions to use alcohol and other
substances.
  However, there is some support in health communication and other behavioral
literature t
 
                  o support a linkage, first, between mass media use and
belief-formation and, second,
 
         between beliefs and the formation of intentions to perform behaviors
(Fishbein & Ajzen,
 
            1975).
Brown and her colleagues linked six expectancies about alcohol, defined as
"anticipated
 
                  consequences of alcohol use,"  to alcohol behavior (Brown,
Goldman, Inn and Anderson,
 
          1980). Although directional causality cannot be determined, they said
"global"  factors
 
            were related to less alcohol consumption while "increased
expectation of sexual and
 
        aggressive behavior (two separate expectancies)"  were associated with
heavier drinking.
A more recent study identifies nine different expectancies about alcohol use as
part of
 
                  development of a "Drinking Expectancy Questionnaire" (Young
and Knight, 1989). The
 
       authors' analysis of a large number of possible expectancies about
alcohol use identified
 
            assertiveness, affective change, sexual enhancement, social
enhancement, relaxation,
 
         cognitive impairment, dependence, carelessness, and aggression as
underlying dimensions.
 
            The authors did not attempt to link these expectancies with media
behavior.
The research documenting the amount of drinking on television entertainment
programs
 
               suggests that underlying messages about expectancies about
alcohol -- the health beliefs--
 in entertainment-television drinking behavior should be examined. This study
examines
 
           health- belief messages about alcohol use embedded in  continuing
entertainment programs
 
            broadcast on prime time and in afternoon soap operas to try to
determine whether a pattern
 of alcohol-belief information is reaching the television audience for these
programs.
 
 
METHOD
Analysis of the health belief messages was based on coding of 56 half hours of
prime-time
 
                  continuing programs and 47 half hours of daytime soaps. The
weeks were selected to avoid
 
            sweeps, with the intent to acquire "average" or nonspecial content.
The number of programs
 coded and the weeks selected were limited by resources.[1]  Programs were taped
during one
 
            week in the spring 1993 season and one week in the fall 1993 season.
Because we are interested in the implications of continuing messages rather than
a
 
             description of one time period, programs selected for prime time
were  those with live
 
           characters in the top-rated programs for each season , selected from
combined ratings
 
          provided by two networks. Excluded were talk shows, news magazines,
sports and movies.
 
           Talk shows, news magazines and sports do not provide intercharacter
messages, and this
 
           study was not examining commercial messages. Movies were excluded
because they do not have
 the potential for continuing messages.
For the soap operas, which air every day, broadcasts of each program were
selected by
 
                random number. Because we were gathering character information
as well, a coder familiar
 
            with continuing characters was assigned the familiar program in
order to make character
 
            information more accurate. [For example, in the soaps, marital
status may not be obvious
 
            from one half hours' viewing. Those who follow a particular soap can
provide more
 
      information.] Other program assignment was random.
Although a week or program selected randomly from the entire season would have
more
 
              generalizability to the television season as a whole, the week
selected here avoids the
 
            special content usually included in prime time when the season
begins and ends and during
 
            sweeps and should be more representative of the season as a whole
than these special
 
         weeks.
In order to cover the widest diversity of programs and to make comparisons
without
 
             weighting, coding was limited to one half hour of each taped
program.For both the
 
      prime-time programs and the soaps, if any program was a full-hour
broadcast the full hour
 was taped and the actual half hour coded for the program was selected randomly
, unless
 
            drinking occurred in one half hour only. Coders were instructed to
view both half hours.
 
            Because we were looking for behaviors associated with alcohol use
rather than just a count
 of alcohol use, if alcohol use occurred in only one of these half hours, the
time with
 
            alcohol use was coded because that was the activity of interest. If
alcohol use occurred
 
            in both half hours, the coder was instructed to code the original
assignment.
Coding Procedures: Each half hour was double coded. Programs were first coded by
graduate
 
                  students in a beginning research methods course. Then the
student coding was verified by
 
            one of two trained coders assigned to the project. Each student was
assigned 3 half hours
 
            of prime time and 3 half hours of afternoon soaps and was provided a
detailed set of
 
         directions, sample code sheets and coding examples, and required to
attend a training
 
          session.
As a reliability check, twenty half-hour programs were double coded by each of
the
 
             supervising coders. An additional random sample of 6 half hours was
verified by both
 
         coders, in effect providing a triple code. On the health beliefs, no
disagreements were
 
            found.
Codes and coding procedures were developed through a pretest of a preliminary
program set.
 The pretest coded by time, determining drinking behavior of each character per
half hour.
  The preliminary coding indicated that drinking, even for the same character,
varied
 
                considerably by scene; therefore an alternative to time or
character  was needed.
Coding:  Coding was conducted in two stages. First general scene information was
recorded.
 Instructions for the scene information relied heavily on Wallack's "TV Coder's
Manual"
 
                  for coding drinking acts (Wallack, et al., 1990). For each
scene, the type of alcohol
 
          behavior and the setting (place, time of day, number of men and number
of women present,
 
            type of people [e.g., business, romantic,etc.] , and mood of the
scene) were coded. In
 
           addition, presence or absence of examples of the Young and Knight
(1989) nine
 
  alcohol-related health beliefs were coded. The type of program was also
recorded.
The second phase of the study, which is not reported here, focused on individual
 
           characters. Perceived demographic information about each character,
the character's role
 
            in the scene, the character's drinking behavior and reason for
drinking, consequences of
 
            this drinking behavior and any cautions mentioned about drinking
were coded.
Because this report is concerned with health belief messages in programs,
relevant is type
 of program and Wallack's definition of use of alcohol, or a "drinking act." If
a
 
            character actually ingested a drink or  prepared to take a drink,
the scene was recorded
 
            as having drinking behavior. In addition,  references to alcohol or
visual alcohol
 
       artifacts were included as drinking behavior. Whether a character
actually drinks a
 
        beverage, orders a drink, or discusses intent  to drink,  certain
messages about alcohol
 
            beliefs may be communicated, and those beliefs are of interest here.
Seven types of programs, based on identification in TV Guide, were identified:
daytime
 
                 soaps, comedy, drama, crime drama, evening soaps, mysteries,
and "other." Coders were
 
          instructed to use the TV Guide identification.
Scene was chosen as the unit of analysis. Time as a unit wasn't giving us
overall
 
            background in the pretest and and had the additional problem of
repetition. For example,
 
            one person could have several drinks in a one scene and be sending
only one message. And
 
            as already mentioned, characters tended to appear in more than one
scene. Scene analysis
 
            allowed us to identify the different messages being sent in
different situations. Because
 
            a scene has a start and finish, scene as the unit of analysis
allowed us to assess the
 
           situation as a whole. Determination of a "scene" followed the
definitions provided for
 
           broadcast script writers (see Armer, 1993, and Miller,1980, for
example). For this
 
       analysis, an abrupt change of time or place constituted a change of
scene.
Coding Health Beliefs: The nine alcohol-related health beliefs were identified
as "alcohol
 reinforcement domains" by  Young and Knight's (1989) factor analysis of a list
of alcohol
 expectancies. Young and Knight had reported three representative items for each
belief.
 
                  The items reflected both positive and negative expectancies.
Coders were provided the list as well as the underlying domain. They were
instructed to
 
                  circle any item that applied to the scene being viewed. Coders
could circle as many as
 
           applied to that scene. If any of the three items for a domain was
marked, the scene was
 
            considered to indicate the overriding belief.
The domains, or beliefs, and the representative items are listed below.
Assertiveness:
                If I'm drinking it's easier to express my feelings.
                Drinking makes me feel  outgoing and friendly.
                I have more self-confidence when I'm drinking.
Affective Change:
                I am more sullen and depressed when drinking alcohol.
                Drinking makes me happy and content.
                Drinking helps me put my life on the right track.
Sexual Enhancement:
                I am more romantic when I drink.
                Drinking makes me more sexually responsive.
                Drinking alcohol makes me think more about sex.
Social Enhancement:
                Social activities are more boring if alcohol is involved.
                When I'm drinking I avoid people or situations for fear of embarrassment.
                Drinking adds a certain warmth to social occasions.
Relaxation:
                I do not drink alcohol to help me unwind after a hard day's or week's work.
                Drinking makes me feel calm.
                Drinking alcohol helps me unwind after a hard day's or week's work.
                Drinking enables me to fall asleep more easily.
Cognitive Impairment:
                I think less clearly when drinking.
                I get better ideas when I am drinking.
                When I drink alcohol I get more easily confused.
Dependence:
                Drinking alcohol is usually associated with other activities.
                I am powerless in the face of alcohol.
                I feel powerful when I drink: as if I can really influence others to do what I
want.
Carelessness:
                I am less concerned about my actions when I'm drinking.
                I am more aware of what I say and do if I'm drinking alcohol.
                When I'm drinking I take extra care of myself and my possessions.
Aggression:
                I control my temper more easily when drinking alcohol.
                Little things annoy me less when I'm drinking.
                Drinking increases my aggressiveness.
 
RESULTS
The coding included half hours of 56 soaps,32 comedy programs, 5 dramas, 4 crime
dramas, 4
 evening soaps, and 2 mysteries.  Drinking behavior varied; only two programs
did not have
 at least one scene without drinking. In other words, 98 percent of the programs
had at
 
                  least one scene without drinking behavior. The actual number
of scenes per program that
 
            did not include drinking behavior ranged from 1 to 16; the mean
number of scenes without
 
            alcohol use was 5.7 across the sample. But because the number of
scenes varied from
 
        program to program, figures based on the number of scenes should be
interpreted with
 
         caution.
As already noted, because the interest was in continuing messages and therefore
continuing
 programs, no movies were coded. There were no programs in the "other" category;
all fit
 
                  into one of the other six established TV Guide categories.
Although some programs were
 
           coded in both time frames (once in fall and once in spring) and each
afternoon soap was
 
            coded more than once, each half hour represents a different program
broadcast (a different
 time) and will be referred to as a "program."
At least one scene of each of the health beliefs was present in the collective
programs.
 
                  As indicated in Table 1, the most frequently identified health
belief (or expectancy about
 alcohol) was that alcohol is perceived as affecting social enhancement; 38
percent of the
 programs sent messages that alcohol use is associated with changes a social
situation.
The second greatest health message sent was that alcohol use is associated with
relaxation
 (26 percent), and the third association was with assertiveness (21 percent).
Following
 
                  these were: affective change (19 percent), sexual enhancement
(16.5 percent), dependence
 
            (15.5 percent), carelessness (14 percent), cognitive impairment (12
percent), and
 
      aggression (11 percent).
 
 
 
                                __________________
                                Table 1 about here
                                __________________
 
Beliefs by Program Type: The next question was whether these beliefs are common
across
 
                 program types or whether specific program types presented
special health beliefs.
Two analyses were done. Chi square analyses were run to determine whether the
presence or
 
                  absence of the health beliefs in at least one scene differed
by program type. Analyses of
 
            variance and t-tests were conducted by program type on the mean
number of scenes including
 each health belief.
Although examining the distribution of health beliefs over the six categories as
a whole
 
                  was interesting, the small number of evening programs in most
of the categories made
 
         comparisons difficult and required that we collapse the categories for
meaningful
 
      analysis. Because we are interested in soaps as a category, evening soaps
were included
 
            with afternoon soaps as a broad "soaps" category; all other evening
programs were
 
      collapsed into a group of other nonsoap prime-time programs.
Differences across Program Types: As indicated in both Tables 1 and 2,
regardless of the
 
                  type of analysis, there was no difference at the .05 level
between soaps and nonsoap
 
          evening programs in presence of five of the health beliefs:  messages
indicating that
 
          alcohol expectations included social enhancement,  assertiveness,
affective change,
 
        dependence, and carelessness were present in as many soaps as in the
nonsoaps.
 
                                __________________
                                Table 2 about here
                                __________________
 
 
Chi square analysis indicated that 39.5 percent of the nonsoap evening programs
had at
 
                 least one scene showing alcohol beliefs dealing with
relaxation, nearly twice as many as
 
            the soaps, 17 percent (chi square = 6.77, df = 1, p = .009). This
difference was even
 
          larger with aggression; 21 percent of the nonsoap evening programs
associated alcohol use
 
            with aggression, compared to 3 percent of the soaps (chi square =
8.13, df = 1, p = .004).
With the other two beliefs, sexual enhancement and cognitive impairment, there
was no
 
                difference in the number of programs including at least one
scene with the health beliefs
 
            (see Table 2).
We also examined by program type the mean number of scenes including each health
belief.
 
                  Because of the high number of scenes without drinking, and
therefore without any of the
 
            health beliefs, the actual means are low, but the differences are
similar to those found
 
            when presence of the beliefs in the programs were examined.
When programs were left in their separate categories, scenes with sexual
enhancement as an
 alcohol belief were higher in the evening soaps (1.00) than in either the
afternoon soaps
 (.14) or the comedy programs (.16);  (F (5,97) = 3.15, p = .011). While
interesting,
 
                these differences are influenced by  the small number of
programs in some of the evening
 
            categories and by one evening soap program that focused on an
alcohol-related accident and
 should be interpreted cautiously.
After collapsing the programs to three: soaps, evening soaps and nonsoap evening
programs,
 sexual enhancement, relaxation, aggression and cognitive impairment showed
differences.
 
                  For sexual enhancement, the results paralleled the uncollapsed
categories; means for soaps
 and evening soaps did not change; mean scenes per program for the nonsoap
evening
 
       programs was .19 (F (2,100) = 7.09, p = .001).  Again, the one evening
soap focusing on an
 alcohol-related incident is influencing this analysis.
The afternoon soaps had  fewer scenes per program (.18)  than the nonsoap
evening programs
 (.58) showing relaxation as an alcohol belief (F (2,100) =5.05, p= .008);
afternoon soaps
 (.09) were much lower than the evening soaps (.75) in showing cognitive
impairment
 
              (F(2,100) = 4.29, p = .016); afternoon soaps (.04) showed fewer
scenes per program than
 
            the nonsoap evening programs (.23) indicating aggression as a health
belief (F(2,100)=
 
           4.30, p = .016).
As indicated earlier, when the programs were further collapsed into soaps and
nonsoap
 
                evening programs, t-test results paralleled the results of the
chi square analyses. The
 
            soaps had about half the number of scenes per program showing
relaxation as a health
 
         belief (.17) as did the nonsoap programs  (.40); (t = -2.55, df =
74.82, p = .013).
 
        Aggression as a health belief was almost negligible in the soaps (.03);
other programs had
 .22 scenes per program showing aggression as a health belief (t = -2.63, df =
53.71, p =
 
            .011).
 
DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS
To our knowledge, this is the first attempt to identify in entertainment
programs the
 
                underlying messages about alcohol that can affect expectancies
or, in our terms, health
 
            beliefs about alcohol use.
The most frequently identified health belief or expectation about alcohol  in
the programs
 overall was that alcohol is perceived as affecting social enhancement; the
second
 
             greatest health message sent was that alcohol use is associated
with relaxation, and the
 
            third association was with assertiveness. Regardless of the type of
analysis, there were
 
            no differences between soaps and nonsoap evening programs in
associating social
 
    enhancement and assertiveness with alcohol, but nonsoap evening programs had
many more
 
           messages associating alcohol use with relaxation.
Five of the other six health beliefs, (affective change, sexual enhancement,
dependence,
 
                  carelessness, and cognitive impairment)  are present equally
between the soaps and nonsoap
 evening programs, but evening nonsoap programs associate alcohol with
aggression more
 
           often than the soaps.
We need to emphasize again that the numbers reported here are the number of
different
 
                programs that include these message, not the number of times the
message appeared per half
 hour or per program. The implication would be that the message may have been
repeated
 
           more than once per program, and therefore the number of messages
would increase.
We must also acknowledge that analysis of a different week during the two
seasons or a
 
                 different television season may produce different results.
However, every effort was made
 
            to use a week that represented the "normal" programming rather than
the highly advertised
 
            season beginning, ending and sweeps.
If we add our information about beliefs about social enhancement messages to the
 
           literature that has found upper class individuals are more likely to
drink than lower
 
          class (Signorielli, 1990) and the "good guys" are drinking (Health and
Fitness News Servi
 
            ce, 1991), the implication is that alcohol is desirable. Even though
the social
 
    enhancement items included beliefs about negative as well as positive
effects on social
 
            situations, the emphasis is on the situation rather than the
individual. With an adolesc
 
            ent population where the words "party" and alcohol are still
synonymous, the message
 
         implied from these studies is a problem.
The frequent association of alcohol with both relaxation and assertiveness sends
a message
 that alcohol can be used as a tool or a cure-all for stress and/or other
problems, a very
 misleading message. The suggestion that alcohol can cure like an aspirin or
that a drink
 
                  can give someone "courage" or self confidence sends a
dangerous message for those who
 
          might be looking for help. The messages about affective change are
again sending the
 
         message  that alcohol can be used to change a mental situation or mood.
The programs containing messages about sexual enhancement could be positive if
with the
 
                  current fear of AIDS they are accepted by the audience as a
warning. Further analysis of
 
            scene mood (see below) should help us understand the framework of
these sexual messages.
Disconcerting is the low number of programs containing messages about aggressive
and
 
               cognitive changes associated with the use of alcohol. The
aggressive belief included items
 about both control of aggression and loss of control.  Most of the aggressive
messages
 
            were in the evening nonsoap programs which included crime dramas and
mysteries. Ignored in
 the belief messages is the real-life association of alcohol use with aggression
that can
 
            lead  to spouse abuse and other aggressive situations.
The same concern exists about the low number of messages about cognitive
impairment, an
 
                  issue that contributes to the number of drunken-driving
arrests and accidents.
Future: This report is the first from a larger project that is exploring health
belief
 
                 messages in entertainment programs. We plan to immediately
continue analysis using more of
 the scene information. For example, the mood and the setting associated with
each belief
 
            message should help us understand more about the information being
transmitted by these
 
            drinking behaviors. Because our particular interest is women, we
plan to then use rating
 
            information to explore the exposure to these beliefs by the female
audience of different
 
            ages.
Additional exploration will be conducted when the character data is available.
As already
 
                  noted, we have gender, profession, role in the scene, and
other demographic-type data.
 
           Again, we are most interested in the female drinkers, but will
examine both genders in
 
           order to compare.  We would also like to acquire archived programs
and conduct the study
 
            on a long-term basis to determine whether patterns of messages have
been broadcast. A long
 term objective is to identify health beliefs in the population as a whole and
determine
 
            whether these beliefs are associated with television viewing
patterns.
 
 
 
 
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------
------------------------------------------------------
 
Table 1:  Percent of programs with at least one scene indicating a
health belief about alcohol use (n=103)
_____________________________________________________________
 
                Health Belief
 
                Social Enhancement                      37.9%
 
                Relaxation                              26.2% B C D
 
                Assertiveness                           21.4%
 
                Affective Change                        19.4%
 
                Sexual Enhancement                      16.5% A C
 
                Dependence                              15.5%
 
                Carelessness                            13.6%
 
                Cognitive Impairment                    11.7% C
 
                Aggression                              10.7% B C D
 
 
A = mean number of scenes different across six program types
B = mean number of scenes different across six program types; no individual
groups
 
             different
C = mean number of scenes different - soaps/evening soaps/other evening programs
D = mean number of scenes different - soaps/other programs
 
 
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------
------------------------------------------------------
 
 
 
 
 
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------
------------------------------------------------------
 
Table 2: Percent of "Soaps" and "Evening Nonsoap Programs" with at least
one scene  indicating a health belief about alcohol use
_____________________________________________________________
                                                        Soaps*          Evening
                                                                        Nonsoaps
                Health Belief                           (n=60)          (n=43)
 
                Social Enhancement                      35.0%           41.9%
 
                Relaxation                              16.7%           39.5%**
 
                Assertiveness                           20.0%           23.3%
 
                Affective Change                        15.0%           25.6%
 
                Sexual Enhancement                      16.7%           16.3%
 
                Dependence                              20.0%              9.3%
 
                Carelessness                            13.3%           14.0%
 
                Cognitive Impairment                    11.7%           11.6%
 
                Aggression                                 3.3%         20.7%**
 
* = Includes evening soaps
** = Significance < .01
 
 
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------
------------------------------------------------------
 
 
 
American Health and PsychologyToday Service.  "TV Drinking Problem,"  Dallas
Morning News,
 November 11 1989, p.3C.
 
A. A. Armer. Writing the Screenplay: TV and Film. Belmont CA: Wadsworth
Publishing Co.,
 
                  1993.
 
S.J. Ball-Rokeach & M.L. DeFleur.  "A Dependency Model of Mass-Media Effects."
 
          Communication Research 3 (January 1976), 3-21.
 
S.A. Brown, M.S. Goldman, A. Inn, and L.R. Anderson. "Expectations of
Reinforcement from
 
                  Alcohol: Their Domain and Relation to Drinking Patterns."
Journal of Consulting and
 
        Clinical Psychology 48 (1980), 419-426.
 
M.L. DeFleur & S.J. Ball-Rokeach.  Theories of Mass Communication, 5th ed., New
York:
 
                 Longman, 1989.
 
S.B. Blume.  Drinking and Pregnancy. Minneapolis, MN: Johnson Institute, 1981.
 
S.B. Blume.  Alcoholism and Depression.  Minneapolis, MN: Johnson Institute,
1984.
 
C.R. Carroll.  Drugs, 2nd ed. Dubuque, IA: William. C. Brown, 1989.
 
B. D. Caudill and G. Alan Marlatt. "Modeling Influences in Social Drinking: An
 
         Experimental Analogue." Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology
43 (1975), 405-415.
 
M. Fishbein & I. Ajzen.  Belief, Attitude, Intention and Behavior. Reading, MA:
 
          Addison-Wesley, 1975.
 
G. Gerbner, L. Gross, M. Morgan and N. Signorielli.  "Living with Television:
The
 
             Dynamics of the Cultivation Process" in J. Bryant and D. Zillmann,
eds., Perspectives on
 
            Media Effects.  Hillsdale NJ:  Lawrence Erlbaum, 1986, pp. 17-40.
 
G. Gerbner, M. Morgan, & N. Signorielli. "Programing Health Portrayals:  What
Viewers See,
 Say, and Do" in D. Pearl, L. Bouthilet, & J. Lazar, eds., Television and
Behavior: Ten
 
                  Years of Scientific Progress and Implications for the Eighties
, Vol. 2.  Rockville MD:
 
            U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, National Institute of
Mental Health, 1982,
 
            pp. 291-307.
 
H.J. Harwood. Economic Costs to Society of Alcohol and Drug Abuse and Mental
Illness.
 
                Research Triangle Park NC: Research Triangle Institute, 1984.
 
Health and Fitness News Service. "Smoking taboo, drinking OK, adolescents say."
Chicago
 
                  Sun-Times, May 28 1991.
 
D. Lowry. "Alcohol Consumption Patterns and Consequences on Prime Time Network
TV."
 
               Journalism Quarterly (Spring 1981): 3 -8.
 
D. McQuail. Mass Communication Theory: An Introduction.  London:  Sage
Publications, 1987.
 
William Miller. Screenwriting for Narrative Film and Television. New York:
Hastings House,
 1980.
 
M. Morgan and N. Signorielli. "Cultivation Analysis:  Conceptualization and
Methodology"
 
                  in N. Signorielli & M. Morgan, eds., Cultivation Analysis:
New Directions in Media
 
        Effects Research.  London:  Sage Publications, 1990.
 
National Council on Alcoholism. Facts on Alcoholism and Alcohol-Related
Problems. New
 
                York: National Council on Alcoholism, 1987.
 
N. Signorielli. "Drinking, Sex, and Violence on Television:  The Cultural
Indicators
 
               Perspective."  Journal of Drug Education 17 (1987), 245-260.
 
N. Signorielli.  "Television and Health: Images and Impact" in C. Atkin & L.
Wallack,
 
                eds., Mass Communication and Public Health: Complexities and
Conflicts.  London: Sage
 
          Publications, 1990.
 
L. Wallack, W. Breed & J. R. DeFoe. "Alcohol and Soap Operas: Drinking in the
Light of
 
                 Day." Journal of Drug Education  15(4) (1985):  365-379.
 
L. Wallack, J. W. Grube, P. A. Maden & W. Breed. "Portrayals of Alcohol on
Prime-Time
 
                Television." Journal of Studies on Alcohol 51(5) (September
1990):  428-437.
 
R. McD. Young and R. G. Knight. "The Drinking Expectancy Questionnaire: A
Revised Measure
 of Alcohol-Related Beliefs." Journal of Psychopathology and Behavioral
Assessment 11
 
                (1989), 99-112.
 
 
 [1]     Because the initial coders were part of a methods class (see below),
weeks for
 
 
          coding had tobe selected after the students understood content
analysis. If a
 program was
 
            preempted, the coders were instructed to tape the week immedi
ately following.

Back to: Top of Message | Previous Page | Main AEJMC Page

Permalink



LIST.MSU.EDU

CataList Email List Search Powered by the LISTSERV Email List Manager