This paper was presented at the Association for Education in Journalism and
Mass Communication in San Antonio, Texas August 2005.
If you have questions about this paper, please contact the author
directly. If you have questions about the archives, email
rakyat [ at ] eparker.org. For an explanation of the subject line,
send email to
[log in to unmask] with just the four words, "get help info aejmc," in the
body (drop the "").
(Feb 2006)
Thank you.
Elliott Parker
====================================================================
Envisioning the Future: E-Government in Taiwan
Tuen-yu Lau
Kevin Y. Wang
University of Washington
Box 353740
Seattle, WA 98195-3740
Phone: 206-685-0124
Fax: 206-545-8881
Email: [log in to unmask]
A paper submitted for review of presentation at the International
Communication Division of Association for Education in Journalism and
Mass Communication annual conference, August 2004.
T.Y. Lau is the director of the Digital Media Master's Program in the
Department of Communications at the University of Washington.
Kevin Wang is a graduate student in the Digital Media Master's
Program in the Department of Communications at the University of Washington.
Abstract
This paper discusses the status of e-government in Taiwan. With
conceptual frameworks that measure the development of e-government in
four phases, this paper surveys websites maintained by three levels
of administrative systems and argues that Taiwan represents a unique
model of e-government. The overall development carries a positive
outlook and coincides with the infrastructural and other
socio-economic factors. At the same time, there also exist several
problems that need to be addressed with systematic solutions.
Envisioning the Future: E-Government in Taiwan
International Communication Division
Abstract
This paper discusses the status of e-government in Taiwan. With
conceptual frameworks that measure the development of e-government in
four phases, this paper surveys websites maintained by three levels
of administrative systems and argues that Taiwan represents a unique
model of e-government. The overall development carries a positive
outlook and coincides with the infrastructural and other
socio-economic factors. At the same time, there also exist several
problems that need to be addressed with systematic solutions.
Envisioning the Future: E-Government in Taiwan
8
Introduction
Despite Taiwan's technological and economic strength, its effort to
create a comprehensive e-government scheme has not been fully
explored in the academic and professional arena. This paper discusses
the status of e-government in Taiwan with a conceptual framework that
measures the development of e-government in four distinct phases. We
analyzed the content of 62 government websites maintained by three
levels of administrative systems and found that Taiwan's approach to
e-government represents a unique model. The government's progress in
this area is on par with its long-term development plan to build an
e-society and coincides with the current infrastructural readiness.
While the overall picture carries a positive outlook, issues that
hinder the adoption of e-government like digital divide and content
management need to be explored with future studies. Considering the
lack of empirical data on e-government in Taiwan, we hope our
research is a starting point that seeks to fill this void.
Research Questions
This study begins with a general research question of: What is the
status of e-government development in Taiwan? When the conceptual
framework that evaluates capabilities in information dissemination,
interaction, transaction and seamless service is applied to
government webs, the following sub-questions can be derived:
1. What is the level of information publishing and dissemination
capability on Taiwan's government websites?
2. What is the level of correspondence service capability and request
for service capability on Taiwan's government websites?
3. What is the level of end-to-end online transaction capability on
Taiwan's government websites?
4. What is the level of vertical (inter-level) linkage and horizontal
(intra-level) linkage on Taiwan's government websites?
In answering these research questions, we will be able to identify
the trends and characteristics of Taiwan's e-government development,
as well as the extent to which the implementation of e-government
coincide with the country's infrastructural readiness and long term
development goal.
Studies of E-Government in Taiwan
Aiming at better management of government and delivery of services,
the digital interfaces where governments nowadays create on the
Internet to extend its influence, service the public, communicate
with the electorate, form an electronic democratic culture and even
present an image of the government globally can be collectively named
as e-governments (Gosling, 2000). Taiwan's ambition to build a
world-class e-government system is led by the Research, Development
and Evaluation Commission (RDEC) under the Executive Yuan. In 2002,
Taiwan's government portal http://www.gov.tw was officially launched,
and by this time, more than 4,400 governmental agencies have
established a web presence (RDEC, 2003). By 2004, the government
hopes to convert at least 40% of the current 1,500 application
services online; enabling all levels of government to establish some
kind of online service; and implementing official document exchange
at all levels of the government through the Internet (RDEC, 2003).
The adoption of e-government in Taiwan is aided by a matured
telecommunications infrastructure and a rising Internet penetration
rate. According to the Ministry of Transportation and Communications
(MOTC), there are 12 million local telephone subscribers (a 57.7%
penetration rate) and 22 million mobile phone subscribers in 2002.
Internet penetration rate is 41% and still rising, while broadband
users have reached 60% (MOTC, 2002). The number of Taiwan's Internet
subscribers reached 7 million and broadband subscribers at 1.4
million, ranked second in the world behind South Korea (RDEC, 2003).
Recently, the mayor of Taipei revealed a plan to establish wireless
networks that covers the entire city by the end of 2005. The
announcement was echoed by administrators in other metropolitan
cities to launch similar, if not as comprehensive, urban wireless
hot-zones. (Yazhou Zhoukan, 2004). These developments in
telecommunications, along with the government's ambition to integrate
ICTs into every corners of the society, amplify the significance of
e-government research in Taiwan.
Previous studies in this area are consistent with contemporary
scholarship in Europe and the United States, which can be generally
categorized in two directions: 1) e-government as a service portal;
and 2) e-government as a political communication medium. Many
e-government studies with the first approach focus on the service,
business, and economic potentials of e-government, emphasizing on how
governments may utilize their digital arms to save cost and increase
efficiency while users may benefit from direct access to information
and services. Studies with this orientation usually appear in the
form of rankings, surveys, or benchmarks, and often started out by
non-academic background, mostly by NGOs or business consultants
(Sofres, 2001). For instance, Accenture (2004), World Market Research
Center (2001), United Nations (2001) and Brown University (West,
2003) have produced comparable reports and surveys based on what
researchers deemed as important indicators of e-government
development. In Taiwan, researches that fall into this category
include studies on the transparency and interactivity of local
government websites (Lee and Huang, 2001; Shi, 2002), usage pattern
and user satisfaction (Lin, 2002; Hsu, 2003; Cheng, 2001), and
human-interface design (Chen, 2002; Huang and Chao, 2001).
On the other hand, the second group of studies places the progress of
e-government under a broader context of digital democracy, aiming at
examining the impact of the Internet and other ICTs on enhancing the
essential elements of democratic society (Grönlund 2002). Empirical
studies that resonate with this model focus on how the Internet can
be translated into political uses and often yield researches works on
who cybercitizens are, how might ICTs initiate government reforms,
what political ends can be accomplished, and what models of democracy
might emerge along with the information age (Hill and Huges, 1998;
Margolis and Resnick, 2002; Hoff, Horrocks, and Tops, 2000). Scholars
in Taiwan have also taken similar steps. For example, Tseng (2003)
analyzed the implication of e-government on administrative
governance. Weng (2001), Shyu (2000) and Lo (2004) observed the
public discussion forums and measured the degree of civic
participation on government websites.
Conceptual Framework
Our study is not specifically aimed at either one of the research
orientation described above. Rather, the goal is to broaden the scope
of analysis with a thorough research on the status of e-government
development in Taiwan. We hope to provide a more comprehensive
picture as well as empirical data for future studies. To that end, we
use the concept proposed by Lau and Abonlhoson (2002), which combines
the communicative model of World Bank (2001), the three-tier model of
Howard (2001), and the four-steps model of Balutis (2001) into an
integrated framework to measure the progress of e-government. This
conceptual framework classifies the adoption of e-government into
four phases: information dissemination, interaction, transaction and
seamless service.
Information dissemination is the initial phase of e-government, with
the government making information available online as a way to
increase convenience and transparency for the public and to save cost
for itself. The interaction phase consists of the ability to contact
government offices in "interactive correspondence" (e.g. email,
message board) or to "request" for services (e.g. search for
documents, checking status of application, reserve public
facilities). An important note is that "request" for services does
not suggest a complete transaction and may still require either a
follow up telephone call or a physical presence at local offices. The
third phase is the ability to process transactions online, which
includes completion of service requests online and any end-to-end
digital transactions.
The final phase is termed seamless service, which consists of
horizontal and vertical linkages. Horizontal linkage is also known as
intra-level linkage, linking together government websites at the same
level (e.g. central government office links to another central
government office). In contrast, vertical linkage, otherwise known as
inter-level linkage, links between and among different levels of
government (e.g. central government office links to local government
office). These two types of linking practices are not mutually
exclusive. However, if both inter and intra-level linkages are
present, the structure of e-government becomes a seamless web sphere,
where users can browse for services and information at ease, without
knowing the structure and organization of the government.
Table 1 illustrates the characteristics of each phase with some
examples commonly found on e-government websites that fit into each
category. This list is not exhaustive.
Table : Four Phases of E-Government (Lau and Abonlhoson 2002)
Phases of E-Government
Examples
Information Dissemination Phase
Information publishing and dissemination capability
-Events & public announcements
-Information about the agency/office
-Information about the officials
-Tourist information
-Weather & traffic information
Interaction Phase
Correspondence service capability
Request for service capability
-Online inquiry forms
-Message board
-Online survey/polls
-Downloadable forms
-Search for database
Transaction Phase
"End-to-End" transaction capability
-Apply for ID cards
-Reserve public facility
-Renew driver's license
-Paying parking tickets
-Paying income tax
Seamless Service Phase
Horizontal (intra-level) linkage
Vertical (inter-level) linkage
-Links from central government website to another central government
website. (Intra-level linkage)
-Links from local government website to central government website.
(Inter-level linkage)
To further place our analysis in a Taiwanese perspective, we also
categorized our subject of examination according to Taiwan's
administrative and territorial structure into three levels: central
government, secondary government, and local government. Central
government includes the President's Office, the five branches of
government and its direct subordinate commissions and agencies.
Secondary government includes 25 major city/county offices. Local
government includes 336 smaller cities, villages and towns, all of
which are under the jurisdiction of the secondary government.
Table 2 illustrates the three-levels of government with some examples
that fit into the category. This list is not exhaustive.
Table 2: Three Levels of Government in Taiwan
Level of Government
Examples
Central Government
Office of the President, the five executive branches and their
subordinate commissions and offices
-Executive Yuan
-Legislative Yuan
-Judicial Yuan
-Control Yuan
-Examination Yuan
-Other commissions and offices
Secondary Government
Taiwan's 16 administrative counties, 5 municipalities, and 2 special
municipalities
-Taipei County
-Taipei Municipality
-Chia-Yi Municipality
-Taichung Municipality
-Tainan County
-Kaohsiung Municipality
Local Government
The 336 smaller cities, towns and villages under the jurisdiction of
the Secondary Government
-Shihwu Village
-Puli Town
-Daishi Town
-Touliu City
-Taibao City
-Lanyu Village
The four phases of e-government, along with our three-level
stratification of the administrative system, informs our data
gathering and determines the answers to our research question: what
is the status of e-government development in Taiwan.
Methodology
As an exploratory research, the conceptual framework is applied to
examine the central, secondary, and local government in Taiwan. We
located websites of different agencies and offices through the
official government portal (www.gov.tw), hyperlinks from government
websites, and through a thorough search of the two major search
engines in Taiwan: www.tw.yahoo.com and www.yam.com.tw. The website
is then categorized according to our definition of central,
secondary, and local government mentioned earlier.
With all the websites listed in alphabetical order, we tracked the
availability of the website over a 10 month period for continuous web
operation and identified 410 sites as our total population. By means
of random sampling, we selected 62 (15%) for content analysis. Since
Taiwan's Executive Branch consists of more agencies and offices than
other branches of central government (thus more websites), we used
further stratification method on central government websites to
ensure the representativeness of the result. There are two "must
include" websites in our analysis: the Presidents Office
(www.president.gov.tw) and the My E-Gov Portal (www.gov.tw) because
they are the flagship websites that represent the government. A list
of our samples is documented in Appendix I.
The content of the websites are analyzed and coded by two researchers
with an inter-coder agreement reached 97 percent. The content
analysis of these websites is to determine the level of e-government
that each site has attained. Since the objective is to determine the
informational, responsive and transactional levels of these web
pages, we cannot simply examine the index page of the websites, as
other e-government study does (e.g. Zhang, 2002) in that some
interactive or service features may be hidden in the second or third
layer. Coders, therefore, had to click through every layer and look
at the individual web pages so as to determine if they are
informational, responsive, transactional or a combination of these
characteristics. The coding criteria are specified in our conceptual
framework mentioned earlier.
Findings
Content analysis from our selected sample suggests that the
development of e-government in Taiwan is moving toward a positive
direction. First the information dissemination capability is achieved
at all levels of government, although the range of topics and the
depth of information vary greatly from offices to offices.
As for the interaction phase, the interaction feature is present at
the majority of the websites we examined with the exception of a few
local government sties. Our data suggests that secondary governments
have the most comprehensive interactive features, including both
"inquiry" and "request" type of interaction on their websites.
Citizens have the opportunity to submit online inquiry form, to
request services, to search for regulatory database, or to
participate in online polls and surveys. By contrast, interaction
function on the majority of central and local government websites is
limited. Most central government sites offer some kind of database
search while local government sites provide online inquiry forms.
When it comes to transactional capabilities, while 54 percent of the
websites offer forms for users to download, the majority of the
websites we surveyed at all three levels of governments do not
provide transactional services online. However, this does not mean
that the transactional phase is not achieved in Taiwan's development
for e-government: nearly all websites (98%) links back to the central
online transaction portal (www.gov.tw), where users can complete a
wide range of transactions online.
Lastly, seamless service phase is not quite achieved by websites at
all three levels of governments. Most of the websites include
vertical (inter-level) linkages that connect subordinates to
supervising departments/offices. Almost all websites also link to the
central e-government portal. By contrast, horizontal (intra-level)
linkage is not as common. Only 66% of the websites we surveyed have
links to offices at the same level. The following table shows a
summary of our findings:
Table 3: E-Government in Taiwan
Phases of E-Government
Taiwan
Information Dissemination Phase Reached….
Central-
YES
Secondary-
YES
Local-
YES
Interaction Phase Reached
Central-
YES
Secondary-
YES
Local-
YES, but mostly correspondence inquiry
Transaction Phase Reached….
Transaction capability is not present on individual website, but all
re-direct transactional web traffic to the central portal www.gov.tw,
which has online transaction capability. Individual websites offer
forms to download.
Central-
NO (Links to central transaction portal)
Secondary-
NO (Links to central transaction portal)
Local-
NO (Links to central transaction portal)
Seamless Service Reached…
Central-
YES
Secondary
YES
Local-
YES (Vertical, inter-level linkage only).
Discussions & Analysis
Two key characteristics about Taiwan's e-government program stand out
from our observation. First is that the specific information,
interaction, and transactional functions available on the websites
often parallel with the function and purpose of the particular
office/agency. For example, many regulatory agencies in the central
government tend to offer citizens opportunities to learn more about
the application of certain laws and regulations, rather than
providing opportunities for direct interaction. In contrast,
secondary and local government websites tend to offer essential
everyday information and the overall content often reflects such
day-to-day interaction because these authorities bear the
responsibilities of ensuring the quality of life for their residents.
This attribute is found consistent across the three levels of
government and shows that administration officials in Taiwan
understand the "service potential" of e-government.
Second, the structure and organization of Taiwan's e-government
reflects a single-service window approach. As mentioned earlier, the
transaction and seamless service capability is not present at the
individual agency/department website. Instead, they are re-directed
to the central e-government portal (www.gov.tw). The transaction
section on this central portal offers a vast collection downloadable
forms and more than 2,000 services to be completed online, all
divided into different categories. In addition to the My E-Gov
portal, many local government websites also redirect online
transaction services to the Village Services Portal
http://www.village.gov.tw, which provides specific online services
tailored to meet the needs of residents in smaller rural towns and villages.
Our study also shows that the current progress status of e-government
is on par with the country's long-term development plan and overall
infrastructure readiness. As mentioned previously, the Taiwanese
government set the goal to convert at least 40% of the current 1,500
application services online by 2004. As we have discovered, the
central e-government portal offers more than 2,000 transactions,
ranging from traditional application forms to many miscellaneous
services such as buying rail tickets. In addition, nearly all (94%)
government agencies have established web presence and provide some
kind of services online, which is a major objective for Taiwan to
jump-start its e-government initiative.
At the same time, the implementation of e-government also parallels
with the situation of digital divide in Taiwan, with urban areas in
the north and west leading the stage while rural regions of south and
east are trailing behind, most of them still remain at the
information dissemination level. This is no surprise – but if the
government's plan is to build an e-society, this is a problem that
cannot be overlooked. In addition, our tracking of website
availability shows that many websites are not "always-on": some
websites are not available during weekends or public holidays, and
22% of government agencies changed their web address during the 10
months tracking period. This is a contradiction to the purpose of
providing 24/7 services to citizens through e-government programs.
Recommendation for Future Studies
It is reasonable to conclude from the result of our study that the
development of e-government in Taiwan has reached an advanced level
with all four phases of our conceptual framework achieved and a
centralized e-government service portal, where users can fetch
information, interact with government officials, or complete their
transactions – all at one stop. However, as we have pointed out,
Taiwan's e-government development still faces many difficult
challenges such as digital divide and content management.
Our research also opens the door for many future studies. For
instance, is Taiwan's e-government model more cost-effective than
others? What about the social, political and economic implication of
Taiwan's e-government? Does the Taiwanese government have a plan to
cope with the increasing digital divide? These are some of the
research questions that should be considered for future explorations.
As for the evaluation of e-government, a continual effort to measure
both the goal of the government and the needs of the users, including
the government agencies, businesses and citizens, is essential.
To summarize, Taiwan is only one of many successful e-government
examples in the world. For e-government practitioners in both public
and private sectors, it is important to recognize that the road to
e-governance is often a trial-and-error process. There is no
universal solution to address the needs of different nations and its
citizens. Individual governments should explore the experience of
others and determine what can they provide, and what does the people
want. To that end, our paper offers the perspective from Taiwan,
where the government has integrated its vision for digital governance
with the island's economic development plan and successfully created
a unique model of e-government.
Bibliography
Accenture. (2004). E-Government Leadership: High Performance, Maximum
Value. Available at
http://www.accenture.com/xd/xd.asp?it=enweb&xd=industries\government\gove_thought.xml#eGovernment.
(Accessed July 10th 2004)
Balutis, A. (2001). E-Government 2001, Part I: Understanding the
Challenge and Evolving Strategies. The Public Manager. (Spring), 33.
Balutis, A. (2001). E-Government 2001, Part II: Evolving Strategies
for Action. The Public Manager. (Fall), 41.
Chen, C. T. (2002). Study and Implementation for the Human-Computer
Interface of a Government Portal – Case Study: The E-Government
Portal of Taiwan. Unpublished master's thesis, Chung Yuan Christian
University, Taiwan.
Cheng, C. S. (2001). Developing a Customer-Oriented Performance
Evaluation Scale System for E-Government. Unpublished master's
thesis, Yuan-Ze University, Taiwan.
Gosling, P. (2000). Government in the Digital Age. London: Bowerdean
Publishing.
Grönlund, A. (2002). Electronic Government: Design, Applications &
Management. Hershey, PA: Idea Group Publishing.
Hill, K. and Hughes, J. (1998). Cyberpolitics: Citizen Activism in
the Age of the Internet. Lanham, MD: Rowman and Littlefield.
Hoff, J., Horrocks, I. & Tops, P. (2000). Democratic Governance and
New Technology. New York, NY: Routledge.
Howard, M. (2001). E-Government Across the Globe: How will "e" Change
Government?. Government Finance Review. (August), 6-9.
Hsu, C. W. (2003). Using the User-Approach to Analyze the Portal of
E-Government on Service Functions. Unpublished master's thesis,
National Sun Yat-Sen University, Taiwan.
Huang, C. J. and Chao, M. H. (2001). Managing WWW in Public
Administration: Uses and Misuses. Government Information Quarterly.
Vol 18: 357-373.
Lau, T.Y. and Aboulhoson, M. (2002). Adoption of e-Government in
Three Latin American Countries: Argentina, Brazil and Mexico.
Unpublished manuscript.
Lee, C. P. and Huang, C. J. (2001). Web Design for E-governance:
Evaluating the Web Sites of the Local Governments in Taiwan. The
Chinese Public Administration Review. Vol 69: 47-73.
Lin, M. T. (2003). Information Service Function and Usage Pattern of
Government Integrated Portal Site. Unpublished master's thesis,
National Sun Yat-Sen University, Taiwan.
Lo, Gin. (2004). Realization and Reality of Cyber Deliberative
Democracy: An Examination of Local Government Cyber Public Forums in
Taiwan. Unpublished master's thesis, Thunghai University, Taiwan.
Margolis, M. and Resnick, D. (2002). Politics As Usual: The
Cyberspace Revolution. Thousand Oaks: Sage Publications.
Ministry of Transportation and Communications. (2002). Media Usage
Statistics in Taiwan. Available at
http://www.dgt.gov.tw/Chinese/Data-statistics/data-statistics.shtml
(Accessed March 28th 2003)
Research, Development and Evaluation Commission, Executive Yuan.
(2001). Electronic Government Program 2001-2004. Available in Chinese
at http://www.gov.tw/e_govermnent/files/egov_program041101.pdf
(Accessed March 10th 2004)
Research, Development and Evaluation Commission, Executive Yuan.
(2003). My E-Government – the E-government Entry Point of Taiwan.
Available at http://www.gov.tw/about/honor3-2.htm (Accessed March 10th 2004)
Research, Development and Evaluation Commission, Executive Yuan.
(2003). E-Government in Taiwan – Policy, Strategy, and Status.
Shi, Y. C. (2002). Electronic Government in Taiwan: A Study on
Attributes of the Local Government Websites. Unpublished master's
thesis, Nan-Hua University, Taiwan.
Shyu, C. W. (2000). Internet and Citizen Participation. Unpublished
master's thesis, National Chengchi University, Taiwan.
Sofres, T. N. (2001). Government Online: international perspective.
Benchmarking Research Study.
Taiwan Network Information Center. (2002). Survey on Internet Usage
in Taiwan - September 2002. Available at
http://www.twnic.net/total/total_01.htm (Accessed March 30th 2003)
Tesng, T. Y. (2003). The Impact of E-Government on Administrative
Governance: A Case Study on the Bureau of Foreign Trade. Unpublished
doctoral dissertation, National Chengchi University, Taiwan.
United Nations Online Network in Public Administration and Finance.
(2001). Benchmarking E-government: A Global Perspective. Available at
http://www.unpan.org/egovernment2.asp (Accessed June 30th 2004)
Weng, F. Y. (2001). Democratic Administration and Electronic
Democracy: A Study of Local Government On-Line Public Discussion
Forums. Unpublished master's thesis, Thunghai University, Taiwan.
West, D. (2003). Global E-Government Full Report 2003. Brown
University Center for Public Policy. Available at
http://www.insidepolitics.org/egovt03int.pdf (Accessed February 20th 2004)
World Markets Research Centre. (2001). Global E-Government Survey.
Available at http://www.worldmarketsanalysis.com/pdf/e-govreport.pdf.
(Accessed July 10th 2004)
Wireless Taipei – World's Number One. (2004, September 26). Yazhou
Zoukan, 18-26.
Zhang, J. (2002). Will the Government serve the People? The
development of Chinese e-government. New Media and Society. Vol 4(2): 163-184.
Appendix : Sample E-Government Websites
URL
Availability 03/03
Availability 01/04
Central Government
E-Government Gateway
http://www.gov.tw/
YES
YES
Office of the President
http://www.president.gov.tw/
YES
YES
Research Development and Evaluation Commission
http://www.rdec.gov.tw/home/
YES
YES
Atomic Energy Council
http://www.aec.gov.tw/
YES
YES
Council on Physical Fitness and Sports
http://media.justsports.net.tw/spo_demo/index.asp
YES
YES
Taiwan Forestry Bureau
http://www.forest.gov.tw/
YES
YES
Commission on Women's Rights Promotion
http://cwrp.moi.gov.tw/
YES
YES
Civil Aeronautics Administration
http://www.caa.gov.tw/
YES
YES
Construction and Planning Administration
http://www.cpami.gov.tw/Welcome.htm
YES
YES
National Police Administration
http://www.npa.gov.tw/
YES
YES
Ministry of Education
http://www.edu.tw/
YES
YES
Water Resources Agency
http://www.wra.gov.tw/
YES
YES
Department of Industrial Technology
http://doit.moea.gov.tw/
YES
YES
Bureau of Health Promotion
http://www.bhp.doh.gov.tw/
YES
YES
Ministry of Civil Service
http://www.mocs.gov.tw/
YES
YES
Secondary Government
Taipei County
http://www.tpc.gov.tw/
YES
YES
Chiayi City
http://www.chiayi.gov.tw/
YES
YES
Kaohsiung County
http://www.kscg.gov.tw/
YES
YES
Pingtung County
http://www.pthg.gov.tw/
YES
YES
Local Government
Panchiao City
http://www.panchiao.gov.tw
YES
YES
Sanchung City
http://www.sco.gov.tw
YES
YES
Shrding Village
http://www.shrding.tpc.gov.tw
YES
YES
Pingshi Village
http://www.pingshi.tpc.gov.tw
YES
YES
Dashi Town
http://www.dashi.gov.tw
YES
YES
Henshan Village
http://www.hchst.gov.tw
YES
YES
Miaoli City
http://web.mlcg.gov.tw/
YES
YES
Shihwu Village
http://www.shihwu.gov.tw/
YES
YES
Chushang Town
http://www.chushang.gov.tw/
YES
YES
Puli Town
http://village.nthg.gov.tw/puli/
YES
YES
Jenai Village
http://village.nthg.gov.tw/jenai/
YES
YES
Dadu Village
http://www.dadu.gov.tw/
YES
YES
Wujih Village
http://www.wujihtcc.gov.tw/
YES
YES
Fanyuan Village
http://www.chhg.gov.tw/chhgtown/town03/index.asp
YES
YES
Erhliin Town
http://www.erhlin.gov.tw/
YES
YES
Dacheng Village
http://www.chhg.gov.tw/chhgtown/town08/index.asp
YES
YES
Touliu City
http://www.dl.gov.tw/
YES
YES
Taihsi Village
http://www.taihsi.gov.tw/
YES
YES
Yuanchang Village
http://w3.yunlin.gov.tw/partment/town/yuanc/index_yuanc.html
YES
YES
Taibao City
http://taibao.cyhg.gov.tw/
NO
YES
Mingshung Village
http://www.msch.gov.tw/
YES
YES
Yichu Village
http://www.yichu.cyhg.gov.tw/
YES
YES
Dungshan Village
http://dungshan.tainan.gov.tw
YES
YES
Shingying City
http://www.sych.gov.tw/
YES
YES
Shiuejia Town
http://shiuejia.tainan.gov.tw
YES
YES
Madou Town
http://madou.tainan.gov.tw
YES
YES
Anding Village
http://anding.tainan.gov.tw
YES
YES
Daliau Village
http://www.daliau.gov.tw/
NO
YES
Yuanan Village
http://service.kscg.gov.tw/kscg/town/16/public.asp?t=1
NO
YES
Kaoshu Village
http://www.pthg.gov.tw/chinese/town/PTT04/default.asp
YES
YES
Jouru Village
http://www.pthg.gov.tw/chinese/town/PTT02/default.asp
YES
YES
Pingtung City
http://www.ptcg.gov.tw/
YES
YES
Taiwu Village
http://www.pthg.gov.tw/chinese/town/PTT28/default.asp
YES
YES
Tungkan Town
http://www.pthg.gov.tw/chinese/town/PTT17/default.asp
YES
YES
Shitsu Village
http://www.pthg.gov.tw/chinese/town/PTT31/default.asp
YES
YES
Kuanshan Town
http://www.kwanshan.gov.tw/
YES
YES
Lanyu Village
http://lanyu.taitung.gov.tw/
NO
YES
Tungshan Village
http://www.dongshan.gov.tw/
YES
YES
Wanrong Village
http://www.hl.gov.tw/hualien/as07/home.htm
YES
YES
Juoshi Village
http://www.hl.gov.tw/hualien/as13/home.htm
YES
YES
Wangan Village
http://www.wangan.gov.tw/
YES
YES
Kingnin Village
http://www.kinmen.gov.tw/?????/admin_d4.aspx
YES
YES
|